There was an error in this gadget

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

A Rat Problem: Reason Enough to Withhold Rent?

In a recent issue of the Apartment Owner's Association magazine, a reader (landlord) wrote in stating he began eviction proceedings against a tenant who contested the case by alleging the landlord refused to take care of a rat problem. The reader/landlord asked for suggestions on how to handle the situation in court. The attorney answering that month's question jokingly suggested the landlord tell the judge that the tenant breached the lease by having pets!

Answer
In fact, the tenant can claim that the landlord's failure to take care of the rat problem is an affirmative defense to eviction proceedings! Under such circumstances, the landlord would not be entitled to regain possession of the premises (cannot evict you at that time). In legal terms, this means that the landlord breached the warranty of habitability inherent in a residential tenancy. Your duty to pay rent as a tenant is dependent on the landlord providing you with premises that are habitable.

The Law
In the landmark case of Green v. Superior Court, the California Supreme Court held that a warranty of habitability is implied in ALL residential rental agreements. California statute also prohibits landlords from keeping premises "untenantable". (See Civil Code 1941.1) In our rat problem case, this means that the landlord must keep clean and sanitary premises - building, grounds and common areas that are sanitary and free from rodents and vermin!

However, landlords are not required to make sure the premises are in a perfect, and beautiful condition. There must be a substantial lack of clean and sanitary conditions. For example, the following were determined to be substantial violations:

  • Lack of heat in four of tenant's rooms, vermin, malfunctioning plumbing, collapse and non-repair of bathroom ceiling, bad wiring, and illegally installed stove. (Green v. Superior Court)
  • Hazardous electrical wiring, raw sewage seepage under building, infestation of rats, termites and other vermin, old and broken doors and windows, lack of heat, and leaks. (Rivera v. Sassoon)
  • Wall cracks, peeling paint, water leaks, heating problems, broken windows, and rodents. (Knight v. Hallsthammer)
Although the above cases involve rodents with other terrible problems, an intense rate problem (substantial infestation) could come to the level of a breach by the landlord if the landlord does not take care of the problem.

There must be Notice to Landlord with Opportunity to Repair
The law does not hold landlords accountable for problems that they were not aware of or for problems that would not have been disclosed by a reasonable inspection. Thus, in order to assert a breach of the warranty of habitability the landlord must have notice! This means the tenant must tell the landlord of the rat problem in the apartment. The landlord would also have notice if it is clear through "reasonable inspection" that an apartment or building has a rat infestation. Either way, tenants should always be advised to give written notice to their landlords immediately upon discovering an uninhabitable condition! In this written notice, the tenant should state a specific reasonable deadline for remedy in the notice, after which the tenant can initiate a lawsuit. Sometimes asking an attorney to write the letter on the tenant's behalf will light a fire under the landlord to get the job done sooner.


What to do Next:
If you have rats or other vermin in your building, you should:

  1. Obtain an inspection and report from a local agency (health and safety department, building safety department, or housing department)
  2. Follow up on issuance of the citation
  3. Photograph the conditions
  4. Allow inspection by attorneys if the landlord has not fixed the condition


Beware!
The implied warranty of habitability is not a defense when the "breach" was caused by the tenant! You cannot profit from your own wrong. It is the tenant's responsibility to to repair deteriorations and injuries to the premises caused by her own lack of care. This includes disposing of garbage and other waste in a clean and sanitary manner. Therefore, if a tenant(s) keeps an unsanitary apartment or leaves trash and garbage around the building or outside the dumpster (instead of inside) and this results in the "rat problem", the tenant may not be able to blame the landlord.

3 comments:

  1. end of tenancy cleaning The bathroom is the last place to clean. When it is done you may consider your accommodation clean.

    Before the final landlords inspection you may want to check the condition of the furniture too.
    However, if the post tenancy cleaning seams a bit hard for you, you can always hire a professional company for the job. They will get you rid of all the dirt and stains on a pretty decent price and actually very fast. post tenancy cleaning

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for great information you write it very clean. I am very lucky to get this tips from you


    Rat problem Vancouver

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I moved into this house Oct. 2016. It was then I noticed the rat feces in the food cabinets. I cleaned these out before I said anything about rats. I share this house, he rents through the Housing Authority. He sublets 6-7 bedrooms out with HUD. A short time later, I was given my part of the the cabinets for food storage, along with other tenants. I then spotted the feces on my food cabinet, and took pictures, uploaded them, sent them e-mail and nothing was done,and no response. I then seen rats in the food cabinets and tried to video this, but failed. I went to the Housing Authority and complained about this and was given the Housing Inspectors name, number, and e-mail address. After 2 days, I got a response with the Inspector who showed up here, and seen that the rats had opened the food, (dried oats, beans, rice...) and gave him a four week notice to fix this. Now, after my complaint, I have been given a white card on the front door stating there was a civil suit against me. I feel this has something to do with me complaining. Rats leave 4 deadly viruses. Hantavirus,rat bit fever salmonellosis, bubonic plague. all of which if contaminated food is ate, one could die. He would not fix this.. Now, I get problems with him. and don't have the funds to leave.

      Delete